The most important fly fishing question

Have you ever asked or answered this one?
fly fishing a small spring creek
Photo: Earl Harper.

Over the 30+ years that I’ve been writing about fly fishing for trout, I’ve been asked most every question that there is to ask about this particular sport.

“What fly should I fish this evening?” “What’s your favorite rod?” “Can you explain leaders and tippets?” “Why do I keep getting wind knots?” “Do you still guide or have you given it up?” “Do I need to know the scientific names for all these insects?” “What’s better, a blood knot or surgeon’s knot?” “Can you help me with my double haul?”

And then there's “What’s your favorite river?” “What’s your favorite streamer pattern?” “Do trout feed at night?” “Do I need an expensive reel?” “Is an emerger a dry fly?” “What’s the biggest trout you’ve ever landed?” “What’s a reach cast?” “Can I combine a pile cast and a reach cast?” “Which end of your drift boat is the front?” “Can I wear blue jeans under my waders?” “Which direction is this river flowing?” “Do you tie your own flies?”

I could go on, and on, and on. There’s one vital question, though, that rarely comes up. It’s hugely important, though — and definitely worth asking yourself.

How can I enjoy myself more when I’m out on the water?

Here, on the chance that they may prove helpful, are 18 different responses to that particular question.

  1. Fish more frequently than folks who don’t fish very much.
  2. Focus your time on healthy rivers, and especially healthy rivers that feature gorgeous scenery.
  3. Learn to throw beautiful loops at 50’, and to cast dry flies effectively at 20’ or less.
  4. Take more pictures of the river and the landscape, and fewer pictures of the fish that you catch.
  5. Fish with people you really like and avoid fishing with people you don’t like.
  6. Fish on your own from time to time.
  7. Give your fast action trout rods to people who grow tomatoes.
  8. Ignore fly fishing videos on YouTube.
  9. Learn to tie your own flies.
  10. Buy well-built, breathable waders with built-in zippers.
  11. Invest in good wool socks.
  12. Carry plenty of water, along with really good dark chocolate, in your fishing pack. Oh, and don’t forget the toilet paper.
  13. Don’t get hung up on brand names, or labels, or expensive gear.
  14. Spend time browsing John Juracek’s website.
  15. Send Tom Rosenbauer a note explaining why you should be a guest on his fly fishing podcast.
  16. I was kidding. Don’t really send Tom Rosenbauer a note explaining why you should be a guest on his fly fishing podcast.
  17. Remember to be thankful and appreciative when you’re on the water — and to voice that thanks either quietly or aloud.
  18. Fish intentionally, and focus on the various aspects of the sport that you most enjoy.

So that’s it. Do I have more suggestions for enjoying your fishing even more? Yes, I do. But the stuff up above is plenty to think about for right now. Oh, and feel free to share your own suggestions in the comment section.

Comments

Abstain from fishing mono-rigs and Perdigons for 2026. Force feeding trout is borderline abusive. Besides, nothing beats the feel of real fly casting.

Try fishing single fly rigs only.

Stop counting fish; vacuuming the riverbed is not a noble goal. Greed is never good.

Stop reading fly shop/river reports. Be the report.

I answer by saying trout are not the only fish that will take flies. If that's the only fish species/types someone wishes to chase, that's fine, but many other fish species can be a lot of fun to target, and in some beautiful environments too. Be open minded, and expand on the experience and lessons that this sport can provide.

Put some time/money/effort into fisheries conservation. When you enjoy flyfishing you start to worry about the places you fish and doing something about it is better than worrying.

Try a pair of alpaca socks, even when wet wading in your wading boots.

Greet other fishermen on the stream with enthusiasm and as a comrade, even if they are tossing spoons or worms, and especially if they are young.

Pages